IN the grand old days of grand hotels, the hotelier to
be reckoned with was Conrad Hilton. Today, in an era of
specialized lodging, jet-driven business travel, and
clock-conscious guests, it’s J. Willard Marriott, Jr.
Perhaps no chief executive in America provides a better
example of how service cultures are created, nurtured,
and focused from the top down.
Hotels are the most
visible part of Marriott’s business: With more than 400
properties in the U.S. and abroad, the comparison to
Conrad Hilton is not at all outlandish. In addition to
the flagship Marriott line, there are all-suite
Residence Inns for stays of five days or more, and
Marriott Suites for overnighters, plus the
moderate-priced Courtyard by Marriott and low-budget
Fairfield Inn lines. Through its various restaurant
chains (most of them under the Roy Rogers, Bob’s Big
Boy, and original Hot Shoppe’s names) and airline and
airport catering services, Marriott feeds more people
every day than any other organization in the world.
Yet in many ways,
Marriott is not a corporate name. Rather it remains a
family name-one of those rare organizations that has
been able to perpetuate its founders as a corporate
touchstone. J. Willard Marriott, Sr., who started the
company from a nine-seat root beer stand in 1927 (on the
same day that Charles Lindbergh took off for glory),
made a point of being able to call most of his employees
by name. Today, his namesake son is as much
organizational father figure as top executive. It’s his
vision, his sense of corporate mission, his adherence to
strong personal values that drives the company.
Marriott people talk
about themselves as if they really are a family, and
they take an uncommon amount of pride in their work as
part of the worldwide clan. Ask someone like Sam
Slobovitz, a Marriott regional vice president, how an
organization this large goes about creating distinctive
customer service, and you get a pat answer: “It’s
simple. Just find a Bill Marriott to lead the
organization-and I’m only partly kidding.”
Here’s how the management
handbook explains it under the heading The Marriott
Family: “The final description or element of Marriott
Management is perhaps the most difficult to explain to
one who has never worked for Marriott. It is something
you feel in every phase of every operation and is the
strongest underlying influence guiding the company.
Unlike the impersonal coldness of the majority of large
corporations, Marriott has human warmth about it which
transforms the whole into one large team whose members
constantly work for and with each other... Mr. Marriott
does not look at work as drudgery but as an opportunity
for growth, development and accomplishment. He believes
that any honest work is honorable and good for the
individual, so that he or she can progress and gain
satisfaction. Mr. Marriott has always looked at his
organization with the same perspective as he views his
family. The identical principles of cooperation, support
and openness are applied to both 'families.'"
The current Mr. Marriott
credits his father with the philosophy of taking care of
employees as he wanted them to take care of the
customer: "My father knew if he had happy employees, he
would have happy customers and that would result in a
good bottom line." On the evidence-one of the highest
occupancy and lowest turnover rates in the hotel
industry-it works.
At Marriott, there's
nothing inelegant in the details. If someone finds a
departed guest's galoshes, he's expected to take the
initiative and make sure they're returned. Marriott
looks carefully for its kind of people (the company
interviewed forty thousand applicants for twelve hundred
opening-day jobs at the Marriott Marquis Hotel in New
York a couple of years ago), then trains, rewards, and
promotes them when they do things right.
Marriott is big on
promoting internally-30 percent of its managers started
with the company as hourly employees. It pays well, too.
Both factors encourage a lot of employee loyalty.
Marriott also invests heavily in the development of
frontline people, making sure they have the training and
skills to carry out their jobs, whether that involves
cleaning rooms or planning banquets. That promotes
service quality as well as personal growth, and also
engenders no small amount of employee loyalty.
As a result,
customers (especially business customers) continually
rate Marriott as their top choice for lodaina and
meeting facilities. It's the hotel name most preferred
by business travelers. and the top choice of meeting
planners and attendees.
Since 1985 Marriott
has dominated the annual survey of business travelers
conducted by Business Travel News. In 1987, the
magazine's fourth annual study ranked Marriott tops
overall, based on ratings in eleven service‑related
categories-the third consecutive year Marriott led the
pack. Among seventy‑four competitors, Marriott finished
first in five categories and no worse than tenth in the
other six. (What's more, its Courtyard subsidiary
finished eighth overall on its own merits.) In 1986,
Marriott finished first in ten of the eleven
service‑focused categories, including being the easiest
to work with to arrange both individual and group
business travel, plus having the most helpful and
courteous staff, and the highest food quality.
Becoming good is one thing. Staying good is something
else again. Most hotels-and, in fact, most businesses
that have a lot of interaction with their customers-have
a "rate-me sheet" that asks customers to evaluate the
quality of the service provided to them. Marriott calls
its program GSI, or Guest Service Index, and it takes
the data a lot more seriously than most.
In fact, one of the few
mildly annoying things that can happen to you in a
Marriott is feeling almost dunned to fill out a rating
form. They'll ask you at the front desk. They'll put one
on the night table in your room. They'll hand you one in
the restaurant. Some managers go so far as to make a
contest of it-they will buy something like a
two‑hundred‑dollar briefcase and park it on the
registration counter: You fill out your rating card and
toss it in the briefcase along with your business card,
and every week or month or whatever they'll pull out a
business card (the ratings will long since have been
read and acted upon) and award the briefcase to that
guest.
That level of effort is no accident. Each property has a
quota of forms to pass out in order to maintain a high
response rate, because the higher the response rate, the
more complete and accurate the GSI reading, and the
better Marriott can respond to what's happening to
guests in the hotel.
It's interesting how
Marriott handles the information on those forms. The
data is posted in every department for employees to see.
When a problem crops up, however, Marriott works very
hard to focus action and attention on the ratings, not
the people rated. Thus, if customers are waiting thirty
seconds too long in line, those thirty seconds (and not
the people who might have been working the registration
desk at the time) become almost a personified villain.
In addition to the GSI program, which provides local
managers with a running readout of their service
quality, Marriott also attacks on another front. On a
regular but unannounced cycle, every hotel is "shopped"
by a third‑party research company. The effort includes
an nth‑name survey of people who have stayed in the
hotel over the past month. Those ratings go directly to
corporate headquarters, where they can have profound
consequences for a manager's career: Good ratings, high
guest satisfaction numbers, and the property manager's
star will be raising; bad ratings, poor guest‑generated
feedback, and a regional "swat team" may descend on the
property to straighten things out.
It truly does start with
Marriott himself. He knows the business inside and out,
and he clearly enjoys it. Like his father before him, he
reads hundreds of comment cards a month and makes
innumerable site visits each year (two hundred
thousand miles annually) to see how things are going out
in the field. When he travels, he makes notes. The next
time back he's likely to stun local personnel by
remarking how much better the lobby looks since they
moved the potted plants closer to the windows or.
replaced the wing chair by the east entrance.
He's also a hands‑on executive. When a new hotel was
being planned for the Walt Disney World complex,
Marriott sat in on focus groups with l meeting planners
to find out what they wanted and needed to organize
top‑quality corporate meetings. One comment he heard was
that the ballroom space wasn't going to be large enough
for large meetings. It didn't take long for Marriott to
acquire adjacent property to provide the, additional
space.
As the introduction to
the company's Success Kit For New Managers explains,
"Our success at Marriott is largely a function of our
service to the guest. Quality service depends on you and
the successful management of your people. If you treat
your people well and guide them in a positive manner,
they in turn will handle the guests with the warmth,
friendliness, and efficiency that are our trademarks. If
you remember little else please remember that we are all
at Marriott to make our guests' visits as comfortable as
possible."
That reflects Marriott's
own approach to his role as chief executive as it
relates to the company's two hundred thousand employees
worldwide: "My job," he explains, "is to motivate them,
teach them, help them, support them, and care about
them. If we take care of them, they’ll take care of the
guests."
Marriott Corporation
One Marriott Drive
Washington, D.C. 20058
1990 Update: The
Marriott family now includes more than 530
properties worldwide. Conventional restaurant
operations have been deemphasized in favor of food
service accounts and airport and turnpike
restaurants.
Back to top
EM BASSY
SUITES HOTELS
A subsidiary of holiday corporation-best known for
holiday inns, the nation's largest hotel chain-Embassy
Suites has been a service leader in its own right
virtually from day one. The first of the nearly one
hundred Embassy Suites around the country opened its
doors in Overland Park, Kansas, in 1984. That same year,
Embassy purchased the 24 properties of the Granada Royal
Hometel chain, the pioneer, under founder Robert E.
Woolley of Phoenix back in 1969, of the all‑suite hotel.
What Woolley recognized,
and what Embassy Suites president Hervey Feldman has
refined into a highly sophisticated business phenomenon,
is that the typical hotel room was designed more for
construction and housekeeping efficiency than for guest
comfort. especially when that guest is a business
traveler or someone seeking a leisurely way to spend a
weekend.
The conventional room,
the most important part of the system that serves the
guest's needs, is dominated by a bed. It's a place to
sleep and little more. When the basic service a hotel
provides is a place to sleep, that's fine. But needs
have a way of changing, especially the needs of business
travelers. The interlocking of companies large and small
on multiregional and national levels has changed and
broadened the standard hotel's service mission to
include providing meeting facilities, dining and banquet
facilities, even trade show and display facilities, all
of them located conveniently close to business addresses
wherever they may be found, rather than centralized in a
downtown core. Extended stays are also, common as
selling becomes more complex, which means many business
travelers end up using their hotel rooms as a
combination meeting room, showroom, and
office‑away‑from‑the‑office.
When relatively larger numbers of people are involved,
the best way to provide business‑oriented facilities is
in separate and distinct meeting roomS, conference and
trade show areas, and restaurants. But when only a
handful of people need to be involved, the hotel room
can serve such a purpose-if, that is, it has been
designed appropriately. Beds, unfortunately, make poor
conference tables. (And in an era when women are
increasingly checking in as business travelers, beds
provide other complications.)
Embassy Suites is a
working example of a company doing something different
to meet a fast‑developing market need. Its success is a
function of "listening sideways"- perceiving and
responding to a new niche rather than competing in a
straight line by replicating standard designs and
services.
In the all suite configuration, the bed is in its proper
place: a bedroom that is physically separated from the
rest of the space available to the guest. In the Embassy
Suites design, the bedroom has its own television and
telephone. In addition to bed and bath, the suite
includes a living room furnished with sofa and chairs, a
combination dining and work area, another television and
telephone, and often a modest wet bar with refrigerator
and microwave oven.
Continuing the design of
Woolley's original Granada Royales (Woolley himself is
the chain's largest franchisee), all Embassy Suites are
built around a central atrium that provides both visual
appeal and personal security-there are no long, lonely
halls to walk. Included in the room rate is a free, full
breakfast, cooked to order in a restaurant located in
the atrium. Guests have been known to wander down to
breakfast in their pajamas, and that's just fine with
the management. It's the kind of "dress code" that says
people feel right at home. Evenings, complimentary
cocktails are served to allow guests, and their guests,
to mix and mingle.
The primary service focus is the business traveler and
his or her clients or prospects, and Embassy Suites
properties are designed from the ground up to serve that
demanding customer's needs. Although every room is a
meeting room in the Embassy Suites scheme of things,
each location also includes a restaurant, lounge,
recreational facilities, and substantial meeting space.
It also includes access to a national group and meeting
services department that has been empowered to book a
prospective customer's meeting into someone else's hotel
if the area's Embassy Suites property can't handle it.
What elevates the Embassy Suites physical and operating
design still another notch is the attention management
pays to the way its people " perform within those
facilities. Periodically, hotels in the system poll
their customers face to face to find out how they're
doing. For a period of a month or more, managers will
buttonhole five guests a day around the hotel and
interview them about their expectations and experiences.
The next day, those guest comments will be posted in the
employee lounge and reviewed by the on-site management
staff. They’ll also be forwarded to the headquarters of
Embassy Suites in Irving, Texas, just outside of Dallas.
Both on‑site and in Irving, those comments-and
occasionally, if infrequently, complaints-will be
studied and analyzed and used as a quality‑control tool.
In 1987, for example, these1 mini‑surveys were conducted
with mote than six thousand guests who rated everything
from how long it took them to check in and out to what
they thought of the free cocktails and breakfasts The
biggest improvement suggested was better free
breakfasts-and Embassy Suites has responded by improving
and expanding the menu.
It also involves its people at every level of the hotel.
The hospitality industry, like many other service
segments, depends a great deal on lower‑paid, often
highly transient workers. Embassy Suites is no
exception. To deliver a quality experience to its
guests, the chain uses a variety of tactics, prominent
among them policies and procedures designed to keep
employees at every level informed, involved, and
motivated.
In addition to the
previous day's guest comments when surveys are being
taken, for example, each property posts its particular
occupancy rate and estimated profits for all employees
to see. When there are profits-and there usually are,
since Embassy Suites, according to fortune, earns
a gross profit margin of 50 percent, about 20 points
better than comparably priced competitors such as
Hilton, Sheraton, and Westin-even the lowest‑paid
workers know they can take home monthly bonuses of one
hundred dollars or more.
If money is one
motivator, personal progress is another. Entry‑level
workers don't have to stay entry‑level, and at Embassy
Suites many don't. At any given time, between 25 and 80
percent of the firm's hourly workers are in training
programs that help them upgrade or expand their skills
and qualify for better‑paying work. That means
housekeepers can aspire to the front desk-and, on the
basis of their training, will be paid a little more for
making beds and cleaning bathtubs while they wait for
their chance to move up. By continually cross‑training
themselves, employees not only learn new jobs qualify
for pay raises as often as every three months.
The best example of upward mobility may be Hervey
Feldman himself. While he spent thirty years learning
the hotel business, almost all of it in the Holiday Inn
system, the first and enduring lessons in hotel service
he recalls date back to his teenage years. As an errand
boy at the Loon Lake Resort in upstate New York, he
earned the minimum wage for everything from washing
dishes to caddying on the golf course-but the $150 a
week he hustled to take home was better than the
paychecks that supported a lot of the families in his
New Jersey neighborhood.
"It taught me the most significant lesson for my future
life," he told the Dallas Business Courier a few years
ago: "Make the employees happy and in turn ask happy
employees to do things to make customers happy After
that, it's all score keeping."
Meanwhile, day-to-day
benefits show up on the frontline, where the hotel’s
guests stand to benefit. Because of the extensive
cross‑training, each Embassy Suites has a ready and
willing pool of workers able to Step in during peak
periods, vacations, or when other workers are in
training classes. That cuts down on delays and pumps up
enthusiasm. A new computerized front‑desk system will
allow any Embassy Suites to pull up guest records system
wide, lending itself to personal service even if the
traveler has never walked through the particular
property's door before.
All that training has another payoff for employees and
employer alike: The current directory of Embassy Suites
locations is expected to more than double by the early
1990s, in keeping with company projections that foresee
the all‑suite segment of the market growing from about 4
percent in 1987 to 20 percent by the turn of the
century. Corporate growth provides personal growth
opportunities for proven achievers.
The immediate acceptance and success of Embassy Suites
shows the risk‑taking was well thought out and based on
a sound assessment of the specifics of its chosen market
segment. Two thirds of the hotel's guests are
businesspeople, and women traveling on business have
taken particular notice: They account for about 25
percent of all hotel business guests; they make up
nearly 40 percent of Embassy Suites' clientele.
It's also indicative of a customer‑centered attitude
that has put this five‑year‑old hotel chain at the top
of the service quality polls for mid-and high‑priced
lodging. In 1987, the experiences of 232,000 readers of
Consumer Reports with the nation's major hotel chains
ranked Embassy Suites number one for customer service in
both the mid‑priced and high‑priced sections of the
industry. And, as Fortune pointed out, the results of
good service are showing up on the bottom line as well.
Embassy Suites, Inc.
A subsidiary of
Holiday Corporation
222 Las Colinas Blvd.
Four Seasons Hotels
Each year, institutional investor magazine asks a panel
of senior bankers and international financiers-each of
whom spends an average of more than eighty nights per
year in hotels around the world-to rate their favorite
hotels. Of the thirteen North American hotels named
among s their top fifty choices worldwide in 1987, four
of the top seven were properties operated by Four
Seasons Hotels, Ltd., of Toronto. The honor roll: The
Pierre, New York; Ritz‑Carlton, Chicago; Four Seasons,
Toronto; Four Seasons, Washington, D.C.
The company's only European entry, the Inn on the Park
in London, also made the list. In fact, 1987 marked the
third consecutive year that all five hotels were ranked
in the top fifty, which means 10 percent of the best
hotels in the world, according to the magazine read by
more than 350,000 top‑level financial executives in 140
countries, belong to the same family.
Institutional Investor isn't the only one to notice Four
Seasons' high quality accommodations. Of the
thirty‑three U.S. hotels described in Rene Lecler's The
300 Best Hotels in the World, four are (or were) Four
Seasons properties: Ritz‑Carlton, Chicago (not to be
confused with the hotels of the separate and no related
Ritz‑Carlton chain, which also come highly rated);
Pierre, New York; Four Seasons, San Antonio (since
sold); Four Seasons‑Clift, San Francisco. When Business
Travel News asked eighteen hundred business travelers
and travel agents to rate hotel chains on eleven quality
categories in 1987, the runner‑up to top‑rated Marriott
was Four Seasons (in a dead heat with the aforementioned
Ritz‑Carlton chain).
Well, sure, you might concede, any big hotel chain
should place a few winners out of its hundreds of
properties. Which is exactly the point: Four Seasons is
not a big hotel chain. It operates just twenty‑two
hotels-fifteen in the U.S., six in Canada and one in
England. It's not an old company, either. It was founded
in Toronto in 1961 and didn't enter the U.S. market
until its 1976 purchase of the Chicago Ritz‑Carlton.
That makes for a pretty high incidence of winners in a
pretty short amount of time.
You could say that's by design. Four Seasons founder and
chairman Isadore Sharp started out as an architect, and
he's the first to admit that' the first hotel he built
was a less than luxurious motor court in the red‑light
district of downtown Toronto. Its interior design,
however, was eye‑catching, and its services quite a bit
above and beyond the norm for a conventional motor inn.
Both were indications of things to come, but in 1961 the
world's great hotels were almost universally
one‑of‑a‑kind independents. The co7ventional wisdom was
that you couldn't duplicate quality in a luxury‑oriented
property. Over the ensuing years, Sharp's company has
become known for conclusively disproving that old
bromide.
According to Canada's Report on Business magazine, it's
"an odd brand of luxury. Call it ascetic hedonism.
Ascetic because Sharp's hotels are small (average size:
340 rooms), unexceptional in their exterior design, and
about as quiet as an art gallery. And they scrupulously
appeal to the ascendant less‑is‑more mentality among
upscale consumers by emphasizing on‑site health and
fitness clubs; low‑car, low‑sodium meals; and low‑ and
non‑alcoholic beverages … But Sharp's hotels are also
hedonistic. Fine appointments, including antique
furnishings, Royal Doulton china and fresh‑cut flowers …
evoke the atmosphere of an ambassadorial residence."
Think of it as a grand hotel on a more modest scale.
Four Seasons concentrates on creating an environment of
understated elegance, whether in a newly built property
or through the refurbishment of a fine hotel whose best
years might seem to be behind it. The Pierre, for
example, was an aging dowager when
Four Seasons purchased it in 1981. Several million
dollars later, it was reborn as one of the world's
premier places to stay. Seattle's majestic Olympic Hotel
was showing its age and had long; since lost its
prominence in the community until Four Seasons devoted
$60 million to its restoration. The Inn on the Park
London (the park is Hyde) was expected to be just one
more pricey entry in an overbuilt Luxury hotel market
when it opened in 1970. Today, it's admired by hoteliers
as well as travelers worldwide, as evidenced by its
consistently high occupancy rate (95 percent or better
in an industry where 70 percent is considered good).
Whether the property is new or old, owned by the company
or operated under a management contract, Four Seasons
dedicates itself to pampering guests. That's a
spare‑few‑expenses philosophy that caters to an
admittedly special clientele.
Yet the way Four Seasons goes about the job of providing
personal service to very demanding guests is no less
noteworthy for its relatively higher price. From the
room service waiter, who cheerfully and sincerely thanks
you for your order as he's serving it, to the hotel's
general manager, who may spend several hours a week
writing letters to his own employees to share guest
comments and commendations with them, the people at a
Four Seasons make an uncommon impression on even the
most jaded traveler. And as customers show over and over
again, they will pay more to be served the way they want
to be. There's something to be said for learning from
the best.
What makes Four Seasons a service leader? Start with
scale of operations. A typical Four Seasons property has
about 350 rooms and suites compared to the 500 or more
that would be found under a competitor's roof: enough to
be profitable, yet not so many that the staff can't
provide personal service to its guests. In contrast to
the rooms, however, public facilities-ballrooms,
restaurants, and the like-are commonly larger than
needed for the hotel itself.
That's because a Four Seasons sees itself as part of the
fabric of its city and tailors itself to the needs of
the local community. Consequently, the hotel itself will
be centrally located, either downtown or in proximity to
an area's corporate headquarters, not parked out by the
airport.
Next, add staff. The average hotel, according to Hotel &
Restaurants International, has about two employees for
every three guest rooms. Four Seasons generally doubles
that staffing norm: four employees for every three
rooms. The more people on duty in the hotel, the more
service they're available to provide.
And the more service they're trained and empowered to
provide. From top to bottom, employees are carefully
selected. Personnel policies have long favored hiring
attitude over experience. If you really want to do the
job right, Four Seasons believes, you can learn how. If
you don't care about the quality of what you do all the
experience in the world won't make for satisfied guests.
Once good people have been found, they're supported with
training and then compensated appropriately. The front
office staff at a Four Seasons may be earning double to
triple the industry norm through a combination of salary
and bonuses; it's not at all unlikely that the uniformed
doorman who welcomes you is a college graduate. To keep
performance focused on guests at each hotel, not
corporate wide, 80 percent of all bonuses and incentives
are tied directly to the individual hotel's
profitability.
Then, think about yourself. What do you like to do, to
eat, to see and hear around you? You're likely to find a
lot of that designed into a Four Seasons‑run hotel.
Though it serves what is generally termed the Luxury end
of the lodging market, Four Seasons isn't trying to
provide luxury. Its focus is on comfort. That means a
residential style that emphasizes tasteful decor,
antiques, original art. It means if you need or want
something, there's a true concierge available to serve
you.
It means if you're trying to stay healthy on the road,
you can find a choice of gourmet selections with just
500 to 650 calories-outstanding food that's low in
cholesterol, low in sodium, and yet doesn't look like
something catered from the coffee shop out by the
interstate. Four Seasons' "Alter native Cuisine" was
introduced back in 1984-as a result of paying attention
to guests and the way their lifestyles were changing.
Paying attention is an important, if sometimes
invisible, skill. The second time you stay at a Four
Seasons, you may feel as if you never left. If you
enjoyed (or abhorred) the view from a certain room the
last time or requested a specific kind of soap, or
wanted an extra pillow, you often find "advance
preparations have been made on your behalf. There's no:
secret involved: On your first visit, the staff took
notes. Literally. And extensively. Your guest history is
part of each hotel's computerized database, and it's
accessible by all hotels in the Four Seasons system It
will be updated this time, too, and every time you come
back
Predictably, the top‑down service imperative is also at
work, beginning with Sharp in Toronto. It's his belief
that the last decade of the century will find an
increasingly sophisticated, better educated, and more
travel-savvy customer checking in at the front desk of
hotels worldwide. That customer wants not just quality,
but the highest value for his or her travel do. To
continue to succeed, Sharp maintains that Four Seasons
must continue to attract the kind of people able to
deliver that value.
Accordingly, general managers are recruited for their
ability to act as the "conductor of a symphony," making
sure all the players make the right kind of music at
just the right time, and in perfect harmony. 'It’s
important that the manager set the correct example for
employees and frequently communicate to his staff,"
Sharp told Hotels & Restaurants International in 1986.
"You must try to ensure that the reality in the working
environment matches the rhetoric, i.e., it's no good to
show your staff all sorts of audiovisuals about how to
be courteous and then have management giving the wrong
example."
From Sharp on down, Four Seasons managers are good
examples of a thoroughgoing service‑quality commitment
that has paid off handsomely for the business-and for
the customers who have made that business an
international success.
Four Seasons Hotels, Inc.
1165 Leslie Street
Toronto, Ontario
M3C 2K8
1990 Update: Ten Four Seasons hotels received
American Automobile Association's Five Diamond Award
in 1990, marking the ninth consecutive year that
Four Seasons, with just twenty‑two properties, has
received the most Five Diamond ratings from AAA.
Back to top
Hyatt Hotels & Resorts
A curious thing happens when people are asked to rate
their favorite hotels. Consistently, they name a lot of
Hyatt locations. Just as consistently, they can't
exactly say why. It isn't the vaulted atrium lobbies-a
Hyatt trademark since it took over and finished
construction of what became the Hyatt Regency Atlanta in
1967-or the glass elevators, or the fancy revolving
rooftop restaurants. There's something about a Hyatt,
some subtle quality of the service and facilities
provided, that keeps bringing people back.
Consistently, it seems, what makes Hyatt stand out in
the hotel business is consistency.
"If ever there was a time when the orange juice had to
be fresh or when the turndown service had to occur in
every instance, it's right now," Hyatt Hotels president
Darryl Hartley‑Leonard told Restaurant Business in 1986.
"If there is parity in hotels, and I think we all
believe there is, then the buyer becomes very intolerant
of things he had been tolerant of in the past. The
customer is totally in control today. He not only has
the opportunity of going to another hotel, he can go to
a very similar hotel."
Hyatt Hotels & Resorts is actually two separate and
olstmct compames that manage or operate hotels under
various Hyatt names (Hyatt, Hyatt Regency, Park Hyatt,
Grand Hyatt, and Regency Club). Hyatt Hotels Corporation
is the North American side of the business. It operates
eighty‑one hotels and twelve resorts in the U.S.,
Canada, and the Caribbean, including the first Hyatt
near the Los Angeles International Airport, which Jay
Pritzker bought in 1957 from a cash‑strapped owner.
Hyatt International's scope includes twenty‑nine hotels
and fifteen resorts in twenty‑six countries. Although
the company doesn't segment in the sense of maintaining
different brand and price categories, its properties
fall under one of four distinct forms: large commercial
hotels (generally located in a downtown area, and often
a key component in a given city's downtown
revitalization efforts); suburban (or "smaller urban")
hotels; resort and convention‑oriented properties; and
small‑but‑luxurious hotels (the Park Hyatts).
The holding company, Hyatt Corporation, is privately
held by the Pritzker family of Chicago, but most of the
hotels under the Hyatt name are owned, either entirely
or substantially, by local investor groups. Hyatt serves
as manager and operator, and sometimes minority
stakeholder. To maintain accountability for service
quality system wide, Hyatt forgoes franchises in favor
of direct, long‑term management responsibility-generally
twenty‑ to thirty‑year contracts-whether or not it has
an equity interest in the property.
In some respects, the Hyatt reputation for consistency
is misleading. It implies a sameness of design and
treatment that doesn't turn out to be the case. In fact,
in marked contrast to cookie‑cutter chains that promise
the same familiar experience from one city to the next,
no two Hyatt’s are alike. That's not to say that
operating standards vary. They don't. But each property
is designed, built, and managed to be an integral
busines5 and civic element in its particular location
and for its specific clientele or market niche.
Since the original "atrium" hotel-the legendary John
Portmann‑designed edifice in Atlanta with its
twenty‑one‑story central core-debuted, the company has
been considered the trendsetter in the upscale hotel
market for its willingness to take chances on new
configurations and innovate in service areas. Its hotels
are visually exciting, run by independent managers given
a good deal of authority by Hyatt's decentralized
operating style. At the same time, Hyatt has been slow
and selective in its growth, a quality‑conscious pace
that has dampened the effects of an overbuilt industry's
current room glut at the high end of the market.
Similarly, the
segmentation that now characterizes the hotel industry
has been part of Hyatt's management style for nearly two
decades. But instead of building separate brand‑named
properties for separate segments of the traveling
public, Hyatt balances their different needs under the
same roof.
For example, the
traditional Hyatt-five hundred or more rooms in a large
metropolitan area-gets high marks from both
discriminating individual travelers and business group
meeting and travel planners. That's because there are
facilities for each, carefully arranged and physically
separated so the individual's desire for privacy and
personal treatment doesn't interfere with the group's
need for large‑scale meeting rooms and entertainment.
For the traveler seeking highly personal service and the
ambience of a smaller property, Hyatt also offers the
Regency Club: one or two floors set aside as a
hotel‑within‑a‑hotel, with separate key access and
concierges.
Within the industry, Hyatt receives high marks for
making hotel food and beverage service profitable. Of
course, it wouldn't be profitable if it weren't
desirable to guests and people in the community who
expect the best from the restaurants in a Hyatt
property. Consequently, food quality is an important
part of the company's service strategy. Some Hyatt’s
have as many as five different full‑service restaurants,
and many also have a gourmet deli located just off the
lobby. That shows up on the bottom line: Where the
average full‑service hotel gets a little under a third
of its Operating revenues from food and beverage
services, 37 percent of Hyatt's revenues come from those
sources.
Hyatt's service system expertise is visible in other
parts of the hotel, too. The company was the first to
provide in‑room amenities such as shampoo and sewing
kits, to offer computerized guest check‑in at larger
(convention‑scale) facilities, and has been a pacesetter
in guest‑appreciated services ranging from fitness and
security programs to express check‑out.
Achieving consistency in a decentralized service culture
is also a matter of good design. Hyatt uses very few
consultants. It also pushes training and management
responsibilities out to regional and property managers.
In fact, all corporate‑level functions, from management
to marketing, are duplicated at the regional and hotel
levels. The effect is much like providing identical
shipments of flowers to a hundred talented gardeners:
The actual plants will be the same in each garden, but
each plot will display a unique flair.
For the future, Hyatt has committed itself to taking its
big‑city style to both flashy, upscale resorts and
smaller‑scale suburban hotel locations. It promises to
be an interesting mix. The new Hyatt Regency Scottsdale
showcases nearly $4 million worth of water wonderland:
ten pools, twenty-eight fountains, forty‑seven
waterfalls, and even a beach. Prototype suburban metro
properties with two to three hundred rooms may have to
forgo atriums and ballrooms to be competitive, but Hyatt
executives promise the smaller size will not be
accompanied by diminished service.
That, after all, wouldn't
be consistent.
Hyatt Hotels Corporation
200 West Madison
Chicago, IL 60606
1990 Update: The
Hyatt family continues to grow: eighty‑eight hotels
and fourteen resorts now operate in the U.S.,
Canada, and the Caribbean; twenty‑nine hotels and
nineteen resorts on the international side. The
Regency Club brand name is no longer used on
properties.‑To make sure everyone has a first‑hand
knowledge of how the business really works, the
company instituted “Hyatt In Touch Day" in 1989,
closing Chicago headquarters so all 375 employees,
from president Darryl Hartley-Leonard to the
receptionists, could spend the day working on the
frontlines in various Hyatt hotels. The practice is
expected to become an annual event, in part as a
response to an internal travel futures study that
identified one of the biggest fears of business
travelers in the ‘90s as "increasingly bad service
from hotels, airlines, and car rental companies."
Back to top
MISSISSIPPI MANAGEMENT INC.
The sign out in front of the hotel in ALABAMA may look
the same as the one back in Massachusetts, but all
properties of the same brand name are not necessarily
created or managed equal. Just like restaurant, car
rental, broadcasting, and other seemingly monolithic
service delivery companies, many national and regional
hotel corporations sell franchises to independent
operators as a cost‑effective way to expand their
systems. Some, in fact, actually operate very few of the
properties that bear their names. Consequently, while
the overall design and quality standards may be the same
coast to coast, there will be significant differences in
day‑today operations that reflect, at least in part,
different service priorities among on‑site managers and
frontline workers.
Thus, Holiday Corporation will point with just)fiable
pride to various examples of good service management
among its company‑owned Holiday Inn properties.
It also will point to some of its franchisees as equally
noteworthy providers of top‑quality service. ln that
context, the name Mississippi Management is sure to come
up. The thirty‑year‑old Jacksonbased company owns and
operates nine well‑above‑average Holiday Inns in five
states around the south, plus an Embassy Suites, a
Ramada Inn, a Seasons Resort, and five Cabot Lodges-the
last its own growing entry into the mid‑level hotel
market.
Mississippi Management is especially noteworthy for the
importance management attaches to maintaining good
service standards at the frontline, and the relatively
high level of investment it routinely makes in programs
to ensure and enhance the treatment it gives its guests.
For example, in the name of service quality it has held
an internal, company‑wide Olympics-with such events as
drink‑mixing, egg‑cracking, table‑clearing, key‑sorting,
and sheet‑and towel‑folding, not to mention the grueling
housekeeping cart relay. Each year, month by month,
there are constant smaller‑scale competitions within and
among its properties, with rewards to the best
reservations centers, the top front desks, the
outstanding kitchens.
No phase of the operation
of a modern hotel is overlooked. Mississippi Management
sends housekeepers to annual seminars and polls
front‑desk clerks for ways to improve check‑in
procedures and incorporate guest feedback into room
furnishings. Every week it rewards the cooks at each
property who come the closest to cutting the prime rib
portions the right size with a ten‑dollar bonus; there's
a similar bonus for the buffet carver who comes closest
to the average serving size. Housekeepers who qualify
for an incentive plan can boost their hourly pay by
making more beds than a property's productivity
standard-provided they continue to pass quality
inspections. Food and beverage managers can increase
their pay by as much as 50 percent through performance
bonuses.
As people stay with the
company, their experience is channeled into an internal
management training program, through which Mississippi
Management "grows" its own general managers. The program
takes six to eight months and includes extensive
on‑the‑job training in every department from
reservations and the front desk to maintenance and food
service. An occasional department manager may be hired
in from the outside, but most mid‑ and top‑level
managers have and continue to come up through the ranks.
One prize graduate is
Cindy O'Cain, general manager of the Cabot Lodge in
Nashville that she opened for Mississippi Management in
1987. O'Cain is also a graduate of the school of hotel
and restaurant administration at Florida State
University, but her experience with Mississippi
Management predates her academic work. She started in
the "hotel business" right out of high school (class of
1978) as a waitress in the company's Holiday Inn in Lake
City,
Florida, and worked her
way up inside a succession of the company's properties
while working her way through first a junior college,
and later Florida State. When she picked up her degree,
she had a pretty good idea who she wanted to work
for-and Mississippi Management lost no time in finding a
place for her.
Many hotel management
companies are unwilling to make such investments,
whether at the frontline or in supervision and
management, even if they are able. The hospitality
industry, they will note by way of explanation' is
characterized by turnover rates as high as 300 percent
annually' especially in low‑status, low‑pay jobs (a
catalog that ranges from the maids in the housekeeping
department to the night clerks on the front desk). Just
bringing new employees up to speed is a sometimes
daunting task.
With turnover among its fourteen hundred employees
averaging less than a third of that industry norm, on
the other hand, Mississippi Management maintains that
its long‑standing practice of investing heavily in
training, motivation, and incentive programs at even the
lowest levels of the company encourages Rood treatment
of guests an builds loyalty and longevity among
employees, no matter how low they stand on the
organizational totem pole. That's why Mississippi
Management bestows every thing from cash awards for
annual anniversaries to a trip anywhere in united States
after fifteen years (twenty‑year veterans earn a
Caribbeancruise for two) on everyone from property
managers to maids.
To further encourage
loyalty and stability among its hourly workers,
Mississippi Management also has introduced a
cafeteria‑style benefits plan, and it plans to add to it
over the next few years as opportunities present
themselves. Child care is already included; a two‑tier
medical plan designed with an eye toward dual‑earner
families where the other spouse already has coverage is
on the way.
The reason: In a job
market where the supply of entry‑level workers is
dwindling, the company believes it will increasingly be
competing for people not just against other hotel
operations, but against the full spectrum of
manufacturing and service businesses. Earle Jones,
Mississippi Management's president considers the pay,
the programs, the promotions, and the perks as
investments in the company's very future.
The return on investment
isn't always easy to measure, but there are ways to make
it visible-and the customer clearly is a beneficiary.
Statistically, or example, about 4 percent of Holiday
Inns' guest comment cards turn up a complaint from a
traveler dissatisfied with his or her stay. The Holiday
Inns run by Mississippi Management consistently receive
25 percent fewer complaints than the national average
for the chain. What's more, a similar comment‑card
feedback system at its own Cabot Lodges has turned up a
continuing average of just one complaint per one hundred
arcs returned since that mini‑chain debuted in 1985.
The hotel industry
undoubtedly will continue to evolve tightly targeted
pricing and property‑design strategies, but the names
travelers will remember will be the ones where they
received the treatment they expected and desired. For
Mississippi Management, the challenge is to make sure
that the two Holiday Inns in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, the
new Cabot Lodge m Nashville, and the other properties it
operates under its own and other names continue to show
up on those lists of personal favorites.
Mississippi Management,
Inc
P.O. Box 16807
Jackson, MS 39236
Back to top